Cheesecake Creme Brûlée

Creme brûlée is one of those desserts that is so simple, yet so satisfying. For some reason, it has a reputation of being fancy, and is seen as a special occasion treat. It might have something to do with being the cliche steakhouse dessert item, or maybe it has a bad rep for being difficult to make at home.

It’s true that it takes some practice to know when a custard is right in that sweet spot of being perfectly done. What else is also true: once you know what a finished custard looks like, it’s one more thing you’ve mastered and now will always know how to do. Here are some key pointers:

  • When checking to see if your custard is done, you want to jiggle the dish and see how the custard moves in the center of the dish.
  • If it’s sloshing around like water, it’s not done yet. This can also look like it’s water moving under a plastic film. The top layer keeps the custard from splashing out the sides, but the sloshing inside is definitely liquid.
  • It’s done if it jiggles like jello. It might be a softer looking jello, but definitely not liquid! You have a few minutes from here to catch it before it over bakes.
  • Once the custard starts to bubble on top and get puffy, hurry! Take it out of the oven! You might still be okay if you caught it early. The puffiness will go back down as the custard cools. The tops will be ugly, but you’re covering with sugar anyways, right?
  • Sorry if your custards have already started to brown on top. That stuff is eggy (not in a good way) and probably so is your custard.

I know not many home cooks have one, BUT, if you have an Immersion Circulator, USE IT!! It’s the best way to cook creme brûlée EVER! No more checking to see if it’s done, and it’s pretty much fool proof. Set it and done sort of thing. Plus the creme brulees last up to a week in the fridge, always ready to be eaten whenever the cravings strike.

One last thing before we dive right into this silky, tangy, deliciousness. 

You don’t need a torch to make creme brûlées at home.

Yes, you heard that right. Simply take a spoon and heat it over flame until very hot. This is now your makeshift torch to melt and caramelize your sugar. Now you have no excuses, go treat yo’self!

Cheesecake Creme Brûlée

Cheesecake Creme Brûlée


For: 7 servings
45 min
Ready in:
2 h 45 min


  1. If baking, preheat oven to 325°F If using sous vide, set water bath to 176°F
  2. Blend all ingredients together, making sure all the sugar is dissolved
  3. Pour into 7- 4oz mason jars
  4. If baking, place mason jars in a larger roasting pan. Fill roasting pan with 1 inch of hot water. Bake for 40-45min at 325°F until set (see blog post for tips on how to tell if custard is done).
  5. If using sous vide, screw on canning lids until finger tight. Cook for 1 hour at 176°F
  6. Chill for a minimum of 2 hours before serving.
  7. When ready to serve, sprinkle an even layer of sugar on top of custards. Melt and caramelize sugar with torch or a very hot spoon.


3 thoughts on “Cheesecake Creme Brûlée

  1. I absolutely love this recipe! Thank you so much for sharing it! I want to make it for someone’s birthday. I do intend to make it this exact way, but I wanted to ask your opinion on doing something a bit differently as well. Would it be possible to alter the recipe (and if so, how)? to make that in a 9 x 13 pan for bars instead of individual portions in the mason jars?

    1. It would be possible but it will be tricky to cook it all the way but not over bake it in such a large container. Have you made creme brûlée before and are familiar with how its supposed to look when done? If so, it would be worth trying but please note you will not be able to slice these. They are going to have a custard consistency. If serving from a 9×13 baking sheet you will have to have a spoon and serve it like pudding.

      1. Thank you for the quick reply. I’m sorry I didn’t respond back. I didn’t get the notification.
        Yes, I am quite familiar with it. I know it wouldn’t be exactly a true Creme brûlée in doing it the way of bars, but I was just curious if it could be converted for a larger group.
        Since we did have a much smaller crowd (of just two), due to lockdown; this worked out quite well. Thank you again! 😁

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *